← Back to Main Site← Back to Blog

Saline vs. Silicone Breast Implants: How to Choose

Ovadia Plastic Surgery·November 17, 2026

Almost every breast implant consultation gets to the same question: saline or silicone? Both are FDA approved, both have been used for decades, and both can give a very nice result. Here is how they differ, and how we help you choose.

What they have in common

Both types have an outer shell made of silicone. The difference is what is inside: sterile salt water in a saline implant, and silicone gel in a silicone implant. Both come in a range of sizes and profiles, both can be placed over or under the chest muscle, and the recovery is the same. At Ovadia Plastic Surgery we use only smooth implants.

Saline implants

  • They are placed empty and filled during surgery.
  • The amount of fill can be adjusted in the operating room, which can help when one breast is slightly larger than the other.
  • If a saline implant leaks, the breast gets smaller over a few days and your body absorbs the salt water. You will know it happened.
  • They tend to feel less like a natural breast, and rippling along the edge of the implant is more likely to be seen or felt, especially in slender patients.
  • They are FDA approved for breast augmentation at age 18 and older.

Silicone gel implants

  • They arrive already filled with a soft gel that holds together.
  • Most patients find that they feel closer to a natural breast, and rippling is less common.
  • If the shell breaks, the gel usually stays where it is, and the breast may look and feel the same. This is called a silent rupture.
  • Because of that, the FDA's current recommendation, as of 2026, is an ultrasound or MRI five to six years after surgery and every two to three years after that.
  • They are FDA approved for breast augmentation at age 22 and older.

How long do they last?

Neither type is a lifetime device. Implants do not need to be replaced on a set schedule, but many patients have another operation at some point, whether to replace an implant or to change size. Read more about breast implant exchange.

Safety

Saline and silicone gel implants share the same main risks: firm scar around the implant (capsular contracture), rupture, and the chance of another operation in the future. Breast implant-associated lymphoma (BIA-ALCL) is rare and is linked to textured implants, whichever filling they have. We use only smooth implants. Before surgery, Dr. Ovadia goes over the implant's patient decision checklist with you.

How we help you choose

There is no single right answer. A few things usually guide the decision:

  • How much natural coverage you have over the implant.
  • How much the feel of the implant matters to you.
  • How you feel about follow-up imaging over the years.

At your consultation we go over both options and build the plan around your body and your goals.

Breast reconstruction and gender-affirming surgery

Both types are FDA approved for breast reconstruction at any age, and the same choice comes up in implant-based breast reconstruction and in gender-affirming breast augmentation.

Ready to talk it through?

Ovadia Plastic Surgery is led by board certified plastic surgeon Dr. Steven Ovadia, with offices in Lower Manhattan, Jersey City, and Millburn, New Jersey. Read more about breast augmentation, send us a message, or call (212) 222-4628 to book a consultation.

Schedule a Consultation

Every patient's needs are unique. Dr. Ovadia will work with you to develop an individualized plan during your consultation.

(212) 222-4628·info@ovadiaps.com